Other tire care products don't come anywhere close to Stoner More Shine Less Time. I think ppl like the others because it put lots of visible 'stuff' (foam, gunk, runny, etc.) on the tire ... they see something so they think they're getting something. This product just goes on, covers, protects and lasts like no other. It is waaaay more natural looking and effective. I use it in the winter and it repels snow, dirt, etc the best of all.